Navigating the Decision: Digital Marketing Agencies vs. In-House Teams

Businesses constantly grapple with the decision of whether to invest in an in-house marketing team or to enlist the services of a digital marketing agency. The landscape changes daily, the goal lines seem to move without warning, and each option presents its own set of advantages and challenges, leaving decision-makers pondering which direction best suits their objectives and resources.

This dilemma was recently explored in a lively conversation on the Inspectations podcast, where host Will Cobb was joined by TAG CEO, Justin Starbird for a dive into the nuances of this decision.



"Navigating the Decision: Digital Marketing Agencies vs. In-House Teams" sheds light on various considerations that businesses must weigh when making this critical choice.

The Question at Hand: Agency vs. In-House

At the heart of the discussion lies the fundamental question: how does a business determine whether to opt for a digital marketing agency or to build an in-house marketing team? The answer, it seems, is not a straightforward one. Factors such as company size, industry, financial resources, and desired outcomes all come into play.

The Case for In-House Teams

In-house marketing teams offer a sense of control and familiarity. Businesses may perceive them as the safer option, assuming they can directly oversee the team's efforts and have greater agility in executing marketing initiatives. However, the reality often presents challenges such as talent acquisition, skill limitations, and the burden of managing employee turnover.

The Appeal of Digital Marketing Agencies

On the other hand, digital marketing agencies provide specialized expertise, scalability, and flexibility. By partnering with an agency, businesses gain access to a diverse skill set without the overhead costs associated with hiring and retaining full-time employees. Agencies can swiftly adapt to changing needs, offering tailored solutions and strategic guidance.

Finding Middle Ground: The Both-And Approach

Rather than viewing the decision as an either-or scenario, it's increasingly being recognized as a "both-and" proposition.

Businesses can leverage the strengths of both in-house teams and external agencies to achieve optimal results.

This hybrid model allows for collaboration, wherein internal stakeholders work alongside agency professionals to execute marketing strategies effectively.

Considerations for Decision-Making

Several factors influence the direction a business may lean toward:

đź“ŤRisk: Contrary to popular belief, hiring internally may pose greater risks, especially concerning employee turnover and skill limitations.
đź“ŤFinancials: While agencies may entail upfront costs, they often prove cost-effective in the long run, considering the diverse expertise they bring to the table.
đź“ŤAgility: In-house teams may offer perceived agility, but agencies can deliver swift and targeted solutions, unencumbered by internal bureaucracy.

Tailoring the Approach to Business Needs

Ultimately, the decision hinges on aligning with the unique needs and objectives of the business. Factors such as company size, industry dynamics, and growth projections play pivotal roles in determining the most suitable approach. It's essential to conduct a thorough assessment, considering short-term goals and long-term sustainability.

As the marketing landscape continues to evolve, businesses must embrace a dynamic and adaptable approach. Rather than viewing the agency versus in-house debate as a binary choice, it's advantageous to embrace a holistic perspective that leverages the strengths of both models. By fostering collaboration and strategic partnerships, businesses can navigate the complexities of modern marketing with confidence and clarity!


As the marketing landscape changes, one thing remains certain: adaptability is key! Whether opting for an in-house team, partnering with a digital marketing agency, or embracing a hybrid approach, the ultimate goal is to tell your brand's story effectively and to resonate with target audiences in meaningful ways. By embracing collaboration and strategic partnerships, you can position yourself to thrive in an increasingly competitive marketplace!

To hear more on the age-old debate: In-house marketing vs marketing agencies listen to, "Navigating the Decision: Digital Marketing Agencies vs. In-House Teams," out now!

Justin Starbird

About the Author: Justin Starbird I have been fortunate to have had several entrepreneurs that came before me take the time to “pull back the curtains” and allow me to be a part of their multi-million dollar companies… and actually value my input. They allowed me to see their mistakes and learn from their real-world lessons so that I wouldn’t have to pay the expensive costs of experience on my own. Additionally, they taught me what really works and the importance of action - not just ideas.

Put The Aebli Group to the test

Our primary goal is to create a platform to ensure that your efforts are scalable and repeatable and in turn, lead to more sales. Interested in working together? Contact us today!

Contact Us
(207) 536-8989